American Idol - Top 8 Girls
01 - Paris Bennet
She is soooooooooo cute! What an entertainer - a 17 year old ball of fire!
I loved her from the beginning - tonight she looks great and sang better than good. I do think she has more in her though. My ONLY concern is that she may be getting a bit of a cocky attitude, which I do not find attractive.
I think all the judges are a bit hard on her because they know how talented she really is and don’t feel she is doing as well as she can.
————–
02 - Lisa Tucker. FABULOUS! 16 years old and a fantastic singer. Nice. Gorgeous. - I’d say she is in the running for sure. Judges a bit hard I think.
—————-
03 - Melissa McGhee. I just do not like this girl! I thought she looked terrible tonight, I loved the song she sang (because I love Heart) but didn’t like her rendition - at all. I was shocked that Randy and Paula liked her. I agree with Simon - “your plane ticket out”.
—————
04 - Kennick Sky. Can we say OFF - KEY? Terrible. Sorry, just BAD. (again, I find myself agreeing with Simon - “plane ticket home”. )
————
05 - Katharine McPhee. Very Cute, and I think she is just sexy enough without over-doing it. I loved her clothes - great shirt, great jeans! And - she can sing! AWESOME.
————
06 - Ayla Brown. 17 years old. Nice girl - Just not impressed.
—————
07 - Mandisa - “I’m Every Woman”.
I LOVE HER! She has got it ALL going on - mature, controlled voice, awesome stage presence. She’s had all that from the begining. Mandisa is better than any one of the girls this season, in my opinion.
Sad thing is I don’t see her winning simply because she is a large woman - I hope I am wrong, but I think there is a prejudice against “largeness” - especially in America.
————
08 - Kellie Pickler. Where’s our little country singer? Why is she singing Melissa Ethridge? Because she is a “naughty little minx” , says Simon. I agree, “not the best singer” but ya know - she’s got something!
She did great - but me thinks she isn’t nearly as much of a dumb country girl as she portrays - smart marketer, perhaps?
The Vote-Off:
I think it’s between Ayla, Kinnick, and Melissa.